Game Theory: FNAF, Return To The Pit (3 New FNAF Theories)
The Game Theorists
SUBSCRIBE to Never Miss A Game Theory! ►

Check out Rhett \u0026 Link's podcast 'Ronstadt' FREE on Spotify \u0026 Apple Podcasts!
Apple Podcast:

Welcome back to MatPat has too many FNAF theories, that he needs to put multiple in an episode! Today we are going to cover 3 more short Five Nights At Freddy's theories, focusing mainly on the new books. From more information on the ever important Cassidy, to William Afton's time travel shenanigans, there is a LOT to cover! Let's dive into this time traveling ball pit, shall we?

Find the game here ►
SUBSCRIBE to Catch all the Theories! ►

0:00 - Theory #1
7:40 - Theory #2
12:53 - Theory #3

Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ►

FNAF, The FINAL Timeline ►►
FNAF, The Monster We MISSED! ►►
FNAF This Theory Changes Everything ►
FNAF, You Were Meant To Lose ►
FNAF 6, No More Secrets ►

Writer: Matthew Patrick
Editors: Tyler Mascola, Pedro Freitas, Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick, and Dan "Cybert" Seibert
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman

  • asa6am

    If matpat keeps making fnaf theories for another three years and a half there will be officially 10 years worth of fnaf game theories

  • Evan Tran99
    Evan Tran99

    so many weird time machines

  • Doyle Orr
    Doyle Orr

    There is a strange pattern. I can’t explain it too well, but we learn the truth for each game in their own respective order, like fnaf 1, 2, 3, and most likely 4 soon.

  • Hi_Im_A_Weeb YT
    Hi_Im_A_Weeb YT

    What if Scott never made a story line for FNAF and mat pat is just making it for him so Scott adds little things so mat pat still makes theory’s and it’s more content for a both of them. And if this is true does that mean MatPat is the creator of the fnaf story line and he wasted almost 8 years of his life making content about a child murder that killed 20+ kids (too many to count) in a Chuck E Cheese style restaurant game that he doesn’t even own? ................. BUT HEY THATS JUST A THEORY A RANDOM THOUGHT IN MY HEAD WHICH IS NOT LIKELY TO BE TRUE LIKE MAT PATS DREAM THEORY FROM FNAF 4 THEORY THANKS FOR READING.

  • Buddy Bear
    Buddy Bear

    Lol I just finished into the pit like two weeks ago

  • Nicholas Epsilon
    Nicholas Epsilon

    hear me out... We are playing as Larson in all the games.. who is experiencing all of these events in flashbacks after being infected by the virus

  • Darla Toten
    Darla Toten

    Pin this if you know when your last FNAF theory is

  • FlowerGames


  • Harmless Avocado
    Harmless Avocado


  • elliebehindyourmom

    anyways matpat created fnaf

  • Reggie Padua
    Reggie Padua

    DROOL 1

  • Reggie Padua
    Reggie Padua


  • The Orbit
    The Orbit

    At this point, these FNAF theories deserve their own channel alongside Game Theory, Film Theory, and Food Theory. There are so many FNAF theories!

  • Julian Carr-de Avelon
    Julian Carr-de Avelon


  • god fears me
    god fears me

    how does it feel owning fnaf now

  • yuno storme
    yuno storme

    The silky leather disappointedly rejoice because platinum mostly level toward a abounding ketchup. agreeable, lowly equinox

  • Fareel Eswandy
    Fareel Eswandy

    Wait so water kills afton

  • Aloe__Alex

    ooh,,, timing-

  • xXelementafoXx

    nobody: a single drop of water: im bouta end this mans whole career

  • GoopyGalaxy

    Really bad timing

  • Sophia M
    Sophia M

    People are saying that mat and Markiplier now run fnaf, what's that about?? Did Scott do something orrr?

    • Salty Tsunie
      Salty Tsunie

      From what I heard Scott was giving money to anti-LGBTQ groups

  • muffin time
    muffin time

    thanks matpat now I can't sleep :/

  • GaboFromHere LIVE
    GaboFromHere LIVE

    That raindrop really **ended him**

  • Raven Ash
    Raven Ash

    Hey so you own five nights at Freddy's now right, please

  • RipHunter77

    I'm not here for FNAF - but I am here for a proposal. For a game theory. Look into Ark:Survival Evolved dear Matpat, look into its deepest lore chasms as it is ending, and Ark:2 is being born...and then refer to this (Watch the Ark Genesis part 2 ending boss fight end cutscene, Syntacs "ARK Genesis Part 2 Ending! - ARK Survival Evolved DLC" is a good one, you can skip the actual boss-fight if you wish) ...Edmund Rockwell...and everyone else can still be alive. If Santiago (Vin Diesels character in Ark:2, big character in Ark:extinction) was respawned on an Ark, and died - and respawned on the Eden half of the Genesis ring's in orbit around the foreign planet - this means Rockwell (Edmund Rockwell), Helena (HLNA as you know her in Genesis), and the rest of the gang (if you looked deep into the Island ark explorer notes, good job then you know who I mean) can still be alive. Rockwell is the big one though because he is what squandered mankinds greatest vessel, forcing the only ring he didnt corrupt with the evil element to be seperated and the rest of the ship destroyed. (If you looked deep enough, youd understand how Rockwell became well, Rockwell as we see in Genesis 2) Also, the specimen implant in survivors means Santiago was able to remember he was respawned before so he kept his memories from being respawned on the Ark's, and this means so will Helena Walker, Rockwell, and everyone else (Maybe) and if so, Rockwell will have learned his lesson and not be corrupt again, assuming there's no sign of element on the planet the Genesis ship found. In his last words he regret his actions, in taking the ship, in everything - Or if he doesn't remember, and his implant was, well, separated in his "transformation" he may repeat his past actions. You probably wont even see this but if so, its a great theory. And probably no one has ever played ark here, its a very friendly community, unlike arks community, but I really want this theory to see the light of day. Alas this is not the way of the world, and this paragraph has a very high likelihood of being forgotten and neglected, and my brain power I used to come up with this theory, wasted. But if you do then that would be very cool and no one here probably knows what I'm talking about but MatPat has the brain power to figure it out with a whole lotta healthy research, so please, consider looking into this. And im only putting this here cause this is the latest video maybe ill put this on your next vid, who knows...but this is about a GAME, and its a THEORY. So consider.

  • taeveon jones
    taeveon jones

    I love this series

  • Kris Avery Averoe
    Kris Avery Averoe

    uh mat uh did you um did you hear abt scott? 👁👄👁

  • Master D
    Master D

    Mat: We can make another video about FNAF with this new lore Team behind Game Theory: Rolling their eyes questioning their life choices

  • Draven Wilson
    Draven Wilson

    100%. Believe Larson will be afton and that’s how the series will end. Thought this since lucky boy

  • Also Rube
    Also Rube

    I found it. The true villain. Dabbing chica. We can't get rid of her.

  • SsSploogeJ2

    Hey new theory the Freddy’s Pizzeria secret menu item deez

  • Michael Solarek
    Michael Solarek

    That second story with asking balloon boy advice sounds like a retelling of a Twilight Zone episode where a couple keep asking a fortune teller at the diner they are at for advice.

  • Dino Gamer
    Dino Gamer

    Theory idea:is there a bad side of roblox?

  • Rachel T
    Rachel T

    We did it guys. It took 7 years but we finally broke him. Matpat finally snapped and ended his fnaf theories. Today is a good day.

  • Just G
    Just G

    Y'all have been doing these theories since I was 15 years old, when are y'all gonna stop xD

  • Ghost Girl / EdifiedErmine
    Ghost Girl / EdifiedErmine

    A new fnaf theory always makes my day

  • memer screamer
    memer screamer

    Scott messed up y’all and he need to pay back .

    • DexterF

      He didn't mess up, sharing his opinion isn't a bad thing

  • Ethan got gaming
    Ethan got gaming


  • Chien Wen Ooi
    Chien Wen Ooi

    Game theory idea, what kind of bones would it take to make the hero’s relics from fire emblem 3 houses?

  • Gabrielle Reggio
    Gabrielle Reggio

    I want a happy ending. Matt say more about happy endings so Scott does that one. 😭😂

  • Troy Price
    Troy Price

    Intro was so funny😂

  • Qq Qqq
    Qq Qqq

    That timeline is going to hit really bad now

  • StrastTheFox

    Ah MatPat, the story writer of FNAF. along with Markiplier, who’s the main dev, and Jacksepticeye who wrote the books.

  • Maize Pendragon
    Maize Pendragon

    I love watching MatPat's theories on FNAF and all, but it really sucks to have Scopophobia and deal with all the images of eyes staring through the screen at you. Aaaaa

  • remember twice
    remember twice

    3:05 "I MADE THIS FOR YOU"

  • Spring Bunny
    Spring Bunny


  • Red Tiger Rt
    Red Tiger Rt

    Hey guys could you please help me get matpat to find out which country would have the best odds of surviving the apocalypse

  • Tygrrs

    Bad timing

  • Buff Mangle
    Buff Mangle

    Regarding that last time loop theory, you should look into Novikov's Autoconsistency Principle, its the exact thing you described (i dont know if thats the exact name because im doing a mental translation from spanish to english 😃👍)

  • That kid with an El Camino
    That kid with an El Camino

    Ahemm sir what was that movie/clip from when the whole lottery thing happend

  • MrBlackBird69

    Wr need to summon the black templar

  • chris thomas
    chris thomas

    The fifth location dummy

    • chris thomas
      chris thomas

      It's your house matpat

  • RAT

    Maybe they spelled Adkin wrong twice to show that’s not actually his name

  • SumoNinja92

    "Time travel loops are real hot right now" shows Looper, an almost 10 year old film...

  • Honey Bee
    Honey Bee

    Wait.. The book number 3 has lore. It helps you with some of the missing pieces.

  • Ghosty Boi
    Ghosty Boi

    0:02 Willam: NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO- the child: sir you dropped your wallet- Willam: AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HEEEELPPPPPPPPPP child: >.>

  • Who cares
    Who cares

    3rd theory seems a lot like the plot from "Earased" (Anime on netflix about a guy going to the past to prevent a series of murders and kidnaping)

  • Hailey Reome
    Hailey Reome

    oh god mark even has mat promoting distractibles

  • Nexus

    Welp this probably is the last theory I think

    • Hayden Fry
      Hayden Fry

      The new game isn’t even out yet he’s definitely gonna make another theory explaining that plus the other books that wrap up the book series. I expect many more theories to come

  • thanos

    at this point you are the owner of fnaf

  • Phrog Pog
    Phrog Pog

    "I always come back" could also be a reference to the time loop

  • Darkos Beast63
    Darkos Beast63

    "I'm about to end this man's whole career"

  • Tenino Foxxe
    Tenino Foxxe

    This was the most wackarse theory I have ever heard from you Matt. I loved it.

  • mister clever
    mister clever

    does anybody else need a summary episode explaining everything

  • Plush Brothers 88
    Plush Brothers 88

    14:08 Who else caught that Community reference? Not only with "The Darkest Timline" but also with the goatie both Evil Abed and Scott rock

  • Plush Brothers 88
    Plush Brothers 88

    14:08 Who else caught that Community reference? Not only with "The Darkest Timline" but also with the goatie both Evil Abed and Scott rock

  • The Everything Channel
    The Everything Channel

    Markiplier theorizing: I always come back!

  • Plush Brothers 88
    Plush Brothers 88

    14:08 Who else caught that Community reference? Not only with "The Darkest Timline" but also with the goatie both Evil Abed and Scott rock

  • Plush Brothers 88
    Plush Brothers 88

    14:08 Who else caught that Community reference? Not only with "The Darkest Timline" but also with the goatie both Evil Abed and Scott rock

  • Plush Brothers 88
    Plush Brothers 88

    14:08 Who else caught that Community reference? Not only with "The Darkest Timline" but also with the goatie both Abed and Scott rock

  • Munir Abdi
    Munir Abdi

    first 10,662 gang lol

  • The true ceadeus.
    The true ceadeus.

    That damn intro I love it

  • BryTheGuy

    And now, Scott will proceed to rewrite all the new books to ensure all of these are not true

  • memeboy420

    14:09 I'm so glad I'm watching Community and I get that reference

  • Daisy Batiansila
    Daisy Batiansila

    Idk why but i think gold freddy is rockstar freddy cus rockstarfredy is trying to protect you

  • SupaSealGaming

    Mabye Cassidy's soul was trapped in the ball pit for a period of time and he didn't actually time travel, he just had a similar experience to the thing that happened to the guy where other's memories were projected?

  • Carol

    the fact i only know this legendary dude from escape the night is sad. i should have been watching these a very long time ago

  • Jake McAfee
    Jake McAfee

    MatPat is truly the real creator of FNaF now

  • a professional
    a professional

    wait dont you have to die from the animatronic to become residue?

  • e

    Theory:there is a ball pit in pizzarea simulator and helpy might be someone aswell. Someone now revgedul lioe the others. I think helpy might be someone or something when he misses the ball pit you lose. The kids might have missed the ball pit and has died.


    OMG!! you realy must watch this


    OMG!! you realy must watch this

  • Evan Pitt
    Evan Pitt

    wow it's matpat the creator of FNAF, look at that

    • Evan Pitt
      Evan Pitt

      @Scott Cotton nah I don't think I will! thanks for the cool recommendation though :)

    • Arthur Garcia
      Arthur Garcia

      @Scott Cotton Huh, I had know idea there was a Scott Cotton. Cool

    • Scott Cotton
      Scott Cotton

      Grow up

  • Rmenn'o'on Mick'kle'len
    Rmenn'o'on Mick'kle'len

    I have some thing that may, or may not [redacted] you off. To those in the comment section ,if you don't like this, then you don't have to read it. you need only ignore it. \/ \/ \/ \/ . VVVVV>>> !>This is a memo to christian.

  • Sure Buddy
    Sure Buddy

    Ah yes Larson aka not Cecil steadman

  • salk79

    william: I always come back! one damn drop of water: I'm about to end this man's whole career

  • Luke Mest
    Luke Mest

    #6 on trending sheeeeeeee

  • Jordon Searles
    Jordon Searles

    Matt no offense but how many times have we heard this is the last game im not saying scott is lieing but maybe just the last of this story line at this point it might be the transfer to the new security breach after what if u were wrong thinking its a hint and things were delayed and really hes hinting to a new start like u also said maybe the last book is the end to afton and the start of a baby villain book thats why its the end hes making the switch to the new villain

    • Jordon Searles
      Jordon Searles

      Aka baby

  • Alex Mansfield
    Alex Mansfield

    Has anyone else considered that the old blood Larson finds in the ball pit could be Williams? I mean look at the cover over the first book clearly thats blood coming out of the eyes of the rabbit suit and it would make sense that its that tone of color because when it comes out of the ball pit that would be the springtrap suit before it rotted but since its in present day it would show that in current time William died in the suit and therefore he would have had vast amounts of damage done to his eye which explains why theres blood on the eyelids of the suit

  • bendyman09


  • David Thebestbeast
    David Thebestbeast

    Check on page 83 of the survival logbook it Cassidy says is this song familiar to you

  • Vex

    Haha jokes on you, I've already listened to them all!


  • Origami Ahsoka
    Origami Ahsoka

    I’m falling behind on the book seriessss

  • Elliott

    You gonna do a vid on scout getting canceled 😢 ngl made me sad

    • Elliott

      @Arthur Garcia true but I don't want scout to get cancelled when there could have been people to help

    • Arthur Garcia
      Arthur Garcia

      I feel like Mat and the Team would want to stay away from that situation. I'm not sure if they'll still make Fnaf videos.